MOVIE TITLE: Whalefall
This unique survival movie released in theaters October 2026.

RATING: PG-13 (for peril, violent content, bloody images, strong language, and thematic content)
LENGTH: 1 hour, 46 minutes (106 minutes)
Movie Review Mom GRADE: B

Featured Product About This Movie:
Whalefall by Daniel Kraus (the bestselling novel that inspired the film!)

IN A NUTSHELL:
Hold onto your scuba tanks, movie lovers! Based on Daniel Kraus’s gripping novel, Whalefall takes the phrase “having a whale of a time” in a terrifyingly literal direction. Scuba diver Jay Gardiner (played by Austin Abrams) plunges into the chilly waters off California’s Monterey coast searching for the remains of his late, estranged father, Mitt (played by Josh Brolin), only to accidentally get caught in a deep-sea tug-of-war between a giant squid and a massive sperm whale. Swallowed alive and trapped inside the leviathan’s pitch-black belly with just one hour of oxygen left in his tank, Jay has to MacGyver his way out using the tough-love diving lessons his dad drilled into him growing up. Think 127 Hours meets Jonah and the Whale, with a whole lot of heart and claustrophobia mixed in!
The film was directed by Brian Duffield, who also co-wrote the screenplay with Daniel Kraus. They spent weeks with scientists to ensure their film was scientifically accurate.
Together, they produced it with Jeb Brody and Allan Mandelbaum.
Already, the film has been nominated by HMMA for Best Original Score in a Sci-Fi/Fantasy Film for Joseph Trapanese. He later admitted that this was the most difficult film he had ever worked on. More than 100 musicians performed the music.

TIPS FOR PARENTS:
Don’t let the ocean setting fool you; this is definitely not a lighthearted Free Willy family outing! While older teens who love intense survival thrillers will be glued to their seats, it is far too scary and intense for younger kids. Expect sustained claustrophobic peril, crunching bones, bloody injuries, and gross-out digestive hazards inside the whale. On the language front, there is a sprinkling of profanity, including one F-bomb, about 10 S-words, and several misuses of God’s name. There is zero sexual content, though there is a brief literary discussion of a Steinbeck novel that mentions prostitutes, plus a tense flashback involving Mitt drinking heavily and verbally berating his son. The film also deals heavily with grief and a terminal cancer diagnosis where a character chooses to end his life on his own terms.

THEMES:
Grief, forgiveness, father-son reconciliation, resilience under pressure, and discovering that the hard lessons our parents teach us often become our lifelines when we least expect it.

THINGS I LIKED:
-
Austin Abrams carries the weight of the film on his shoulders. Spending most of a movie trapped inside a dark, slimy, 12-foot-tall practical whale set is no easy feat, yet Abrams makes every gasp of air and moment of sheer panic feel completely real. He performed almost all of his own stunts, including the scenes under the water in scuba gear. He practiced wearing scuba gear while walking in his neighborhood before filming! He traveled to the Caribbean in real life to a sperm-whale sanctuary to learn more about the species before filming began. He also earned his advanced scuba diving certificate as soon as he was cast. Do you think his character’s name should have been Jonah?
-
Josh Brolin’s gravelly, commanding presence provides the gruff father that Jay kept trying to run away from. Even in flashbacks, Brolin brings gritty intensity and surprising emotional weight to a complicated dad who struggled to show love except through harsh survival rules.
-
Watching that oxygen gauge tick down while Jay battles stomach acid, crushing pressure, and giant squid tentacles will make you forget to breathe right along with him!
-
Knowing the filmmakers actually built a massive, 18-foot-wide practical whale interior rather than relying purely on green screens makes the whole experience look wonderfully visceral.
- Fun fact: The goal was to film real whales, but no whales were seen in the filming area of the ocean for nine days before they planned to film Abrams in the water. Then, three showed up on the very first day! The storytelling shows great respect to whales and their unique, precious presence and contribution in the ocean.
- The title of the movie doesn’t just describe the son falling into a whale while it’s eating. It actually refers to the death of a large whale. During the movie, we’re told that when the carcass of a whale sinks to the bottom of the ocean, its decomposing body can actually supply sustenance to deep-sea organisms for decades!
- We get to learn about sperm whales. For example, did you know they have a second stomach? It’s shown in the film as a slimy chamber, and in real life, it’s filled with acid. While we don’t have a record of a human actually being swallowed by a sperm whale, it could happen. It’s the only whale species that has a throat large enough to swallow a human. The esophagus is extra wide because sperm whales often eat giant squids.
- The movie was filmed at Monastery Beach near Carmel-by-the-Sea, a beautiful yet dangerous beach near where I grew up in California!
- The set pieces are pretty impressive. Four versions of the first stomach were built in New Zealand and then shipped to Los Angeles. The director described it as making almost 3 separate movies because they filmed in a water tank, on location at the ocean, and on sets that looked like the stomach of a whale.
- The sound effects are also noticeably good because we hear the heart of the whale beating next to the goopy stomach sounds.
- The colors of the inside sections of the whale are based on actual sperm whale biology, but they’re also supposed to represent Jay’s emotional state as he travels through the sections.
- Amidst the survival element of the story, there is an allegory that the whale represent’s Jay father.

THINGS I DIDN’T LIKE:
-
Some viewers have complained of flashback whiplash. Just when the tension inside the whale hits a fever pitch, the movie frequently cuts back to land for family memories that occasionally slow down the momentum.
-
Having talents like Elisabeth Shue and John Ortiz on board is always a treat, though you might wish their characters were given a bit more to do.
-
The premise seems ridiculous. Jay wants to recover his father’s remains because his sister mentioned how devastating it was to see their father’s casket empty at his funeral. How would Jay even be able to identify his father’s bones a year later if he could actually find them?

FUNNY LINES:
-
Mitt Gardiner: “You got soft lungs!” / Jay Gardiner: “Better than dead ones.”

INTERESTING LINES:
-
Mitt Gardiner: “In the ocean predators have all the advantages, so, what options does that leave prey like you?”
-
Mitt Gardiner: “I wanted to pass on things I knew, so when it matters, you’ll know what to do.”
-
Huey: “I know your dad was rough on you but he knew what he was talking about, especially down there.”
-
Mitt Gardiner: “Survivors survive.”
- Mitt Gardiner: “The ocean always provides.”
- Mitt Gardiner: “The prey becomes so dangerous that the predators can’t help but let him go.”

MOVIES LIKE THIS YOU ALSO MIGHT LIKE:

WATCH THE Movie Review Mom YOUTUBE REVIEW WITH THIS LINK:
Coming soon!
@MovieReviewMom @TrinaBoice

Thank you so much for your financial support on Patreon!
Be sure to check out all of the gifts you can receive when you donate to Movie Review Mom on Patreon!
https://www.patreon.com/m/MovieReviewMom

Dr. Trina Boice is a university professor, author of 36 books, professional author coach, YouTuber, podcaster, film critic, and mom of 4 awesome sons.







New contest announced!
It’s time for another fun contest with prizes! Every month, everyone who posts a comment...